| ROUND 1 | ROUND 2 | ||
| 1. NY Mets | Gordon Beckham, inf, CWS | 1. Philadelphia | Jordan Zimmerman, sp, Wash |
| 2. Philadelphia | Buster Posey, c, SF | 2. LA Dodgers | Scott Feldman, sp, Tex |
| 3. LA Dodgers l | Tommy Hanson, sp, At | 3. Oakland | Jason Castro, c, Hou |
| 4. Oakland | Jason Heyward, of, Atl | 4. Chicago White Sox* | Freddie Freeman, 1b, Atl |
| 5. Boston* | Neftali Feliz, sp, Tex | 5. Cleveland* | Yonder Alonso, 1b, Cin |
| 6. Milwaukee* | Pedro Alvarez, 3b, Pit | 6. Milwaukee * | Andrew Bailey, rp, Oak |
| 7. Cleveland * | Brett Anderson, sp, Oak | 7. Boston* | Chris Carter, 1b, Oak |
| 8. Chicago White Sox* | Carlos Santana, c, Cle | 8. Texas | Chris Carter, 1b, Oak |
| 9. Texas | Justin Smoak, 1b, Tex | 9. San Francisco | Tommy Hunter, sp, Tex |
| 10. San Francisco | Tyler Flowers, c, CWS | 10. Cincinnati | David Aardsma, rp, Sea |
| 11. Cincinnati | Mike Stanton, of, Fla | 11. Toronto | Brandon Allen, 1b, CWS |
| 12. Toronto | Lars Anderson, 1b, Bos | 12. Chicago Cubs | Casey McGehee, inf, Mil |
| 13. Chicago Cubs | Mat Latos, sp, SD | 13. Detroit | Ryan Perry, rp, Det |
| 14. Detroit | Jhoulys Chacin, sp, Col | 14. San Diego | Kyle Blanks, inf, SD |
| 15. San Diego | Brian Matusz, sp, Bal | 15. Pittsburgh* | Garrett Jones, inf/of, Pitt |
| 16. Atlanta* | Trevor Cahill, sp, Oak | 16. Atlanta* | Matt Dominguez, inf, Fla |
| 17. Pittsburgh* | Randy Wells, sp, ChC | 17. Arizona | Jake Arrieta, sp, Bal |
| 18. Arizona | Tim Beckham, ss, TB | 18. Baltimore | Alex Avila, c, Det |
| 19. Baltimore | Evereth Cabrera, ss, SD | 19. Florida | Brad Bergesen, sp, Bal |
| 20. Florida | Brett Wallace, 3b, Oak | 20. NY Yankees | Bud Norris, sp, Hou |
| 21. NY Yankees | Daniel Bard, rp, Bos | 21. LA Angels | Hector Rondon, of, Cle |
| 22. LA Angels | Derek Holland, sp, Tex | 22. St. Louis | JP Arencibia, c, Tor |
| 23. St. Louis | Logan Morrison, 1b, Fla | 23. Seattle | Kyle Skipworth, c, Fla |
| 24. Seattle | Nolan Reimold, of, Bal | 24. NY Mets | Jess Todd, sp, Stl |
| ROUND 3 | ROUND 4 | ||
| 1. NY Mets | Todd Frazier, of, Cin | NY Mets | PJ Walters, p, Stl |
| 2. Philadelphia | Ross Ohlendorf, sp, Pitt | LA Dodgers | Rick Vandenhurk, sp, Fla |
| 3. LA Dodgers | Jake Fox, inf, ChC | Oakland | Adrian Cardenas, inf, Oak |
| 4. Oakland | Jemile Weeks, 2b, Oak | Boston* | Adam Miller, p, Cle |
| 5. Boston* | Andrew Cashner, p, Chi | Milwaukee* | Peter Bourjos, of, Ana |
| 6. Milwaukee* | Ivan DeJesus Jr., ss, LAD | Cleveland * | Josh Reddick, of, Bos |
| 7. Cleveland * | Aaron Poreda, sp, SD | San Francisco | Sean White, rp, Sea |
| 8. Texas | Drew Stubbs, of, Cin | Toronto | Clayton Mortensen, sp, Oak |
| 9. San Francisco | Mark Trumbo, 1b, Ana | Detroit | Cliff Pennington, ss, Oak |
| 10. Cincinnati | Ryan Roberts, 2b, Ari | San Diego | Kenshin Kawakami, sp, Atl |
| 11. Toronto | Brett Cecil, sp, Tor | Pittsburgh | Julio Bobron, of, Tex |
| 12. Chicago Cubs | Tony Gwynn Jr., of, SD | Florida | Allen Craig, 3b, Stl |
| 13. Detroit | Ronald Belisario, rp, LAD | ||
| 14. San Diego | Destin Hood, of, Wash | ||
| 15. Atlanta* | Michael Brantley, of, Cle | ||
| 16. Pittsburgh* | Shelby Ford, 2b, Pitt | ||
| 17. Florida | Greg Halman, of, Sea | ||
| 18. NY Yankees | Austin Romine, c, NYY | ||
| 19. Seattle | Wilin Rosario, c, Col | ||
| ROUND 5 | |||
| 1. Oakland | Junichi Tazawa, sp, Bos | ||
| 2. Cleveland * | Eric Young, Jr., 2b, Col | ||
| 3. San Diego | Daniel Schlereth, p, Ari | ||
| 4. Pittsburgh* | Johny Gomes, of, Cin | ||